Care Assessment Must Consider Needs of Child
When a local authority carries out a care assessment to determine the needs of a child, the principal object, which must remain in focus at all times, is the child and his or her needs.
Recently, the court heard a case which involved an autistic child with learning difficulties and health problems. The child’s mother was struggling to cope with looking after him at home and a care assessment was ordered to be carried out.
The assessment found that the mother was having such difficulty coping with the boy that her mental and physical health were being impaired. It concluded that the child should be moved to a boarding school which, having previously assessed him, would be able to cope with him.
The local authority’s education and social services panel met some months later and a second assessment was prepared by a social worker. This concluded that the initial assessment had been unduly influenced by the mother’s claim that she was unable to cope and recommended that an additional support package (largely undefined) be given to enable the child to remain at home.
The mother applied for a judicial review of the decision on her son’s behalf, contesting it on several grounds, but most particularly because the local authority had failed to consider the educational, health and social care interests of the child.
The court agreed that the initial care assessment could be considered to place undue emphasis on the needs of the mother rather than the child, but was of the view that the second assessment’s conclusion, that the ‘package of support’ was preferable for the child to a residential placement, was seriously flawed, especially as the package of support to be provided was ‘woolly’ and largely undefined.
At issue here was not only the extent to which the local authority had properly considered the needs of the child – which is their primary duty in such cases –
but also the extent to which it had made a defensible case that its care plan met the child’s needs.
If you are not getting the support you require from your local authority, contact us for advice.
-
Divorce is almost never easy and the financial negotiations can be protracted and difficult, particularly when there are business interests involved. In this article we consider some of the issues surrounding divorce for company directors. In the first...
-
Family break-up is always complicated and when there is a property involved, things can get very complex indeed. In principle, when a couple are cohabiting (not married or in a civil partnership) the property belongs as of right to whoever is shown on the...
-
In spite of reforms introduced in 2003, the Child Support Agency (CSA) was heavily criticised for failing to meet its objectives. With nearly £4 billion worth of unpaid child maintenance estimated to be outstanding, clearly something had to be done....
-
The most important requirements for adoption are that the adopter must be over 21 years of age, the child to be adopted must be under the age of 18 and that joint applications to adopt can only be made by married couples and civil partners. Unmarried couples...
-
We often hear of children being taken into care, but the process by which this occurs is not well known. The Children Act 1989 lays down the circumstances under which it is appropriate for a child to be taken into care or a supervision order made. The...
-
More than 40 per cent of marriages end in divorce (in England and Wales more than 125,000 couples divorce annually) and when one in five of all men and women seeking to end their marriage have already been through one divorce, it is perhaps not surprising...
-
One of the most common myths in English law is that there is such a thing as a ‘common law marriage’. It simply doesn’t exist and this misapprehension has led the Law Commission to suggest proposals giving additional rights to cohabiting...
-
Approximately one in six marriages in the European Union is between persons of different nationalities. Not surprisingly, approximately one in six divorces also involves spouses of different nationalities. This can make for some complexity on divorce as to...
-
Arrangements over the custody of children (called residence arrangements by lawyers) after the breakdown of a relationship are usually best decided without the intervention of the court. Unfortunately, it is not always possible for the two parties to...
-
The most important requirements for adoption are that the adopter must be over 21 years of age, the child to be adopted must be under the age of 18 and that joint applications to adopt can only be made by married couples and civil partners. Unmarried couples...
-
Although divorce is a commonplace occurrence these days, few people going into their first divorce have much idea about how the process operates. Here is a brief guide. The process for dissolution of a civil partnership is essentially the same, as are the...
-
When you begin living together as a couple, without being married, it is best practice to set up a trust deed to make clear your joint wishes and intentions concerning ownership of the house you live in. Preferably, this should be in association with a...
-
The headline-grabbing decisions in a spate of ‘rich list’ divorce cases in 2007 confirmed that the House of Lords (now the Supreme Court) is emphasising that marriage is a partnership and that the relative contributions of...
-
The first Civil Partnerships were formed on 21 December 2005, after the Civil Partnerships Act 2004 came into effect on 5 December 2005. Same-sex marriages contracted abroad, however, have been recognised as valid civil partnerships from 5 December...
-
Under the Housing Act a spouse or civil partner has the right to succeed, in most circumstances, to an assured tenancy where he or she was cohabiting with the deceased immediately before the death. Whilst that is all reasonably clear, the...
-
When it comes to dealing with money and divorce, it is important to know what has to be taken into account and the powers available to arrive at fair decisions. For most couples, the basic problem is how to finance two separate households from income and...
-
Divorce is seldom an easy business, but the problems are compounded when there is a family business involved. The division of the spoils has traditionally been the subject of a great deal of argument, but recent cases have at least clarified the thinking of...
-
The 1989 Children Act aimed to clarify the law regarding who could look after children. One of the main new concepts introduced by the Act was that of ‘Parental Responsibility’ (PR). This is the legal term which emphasises that the duty to...
-
Following a recent decision in the Court of Appeal, in which a pre-nuptial agreement entered into by a German heiress and her husband was held to be enforceable, wealthy families worried about preserving family assets in the event of a divorce should...
The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.
